Read As Thou Wilt: Kushiel’s Chosen Week One

The readalong for Kushiel’s Chosen, sequel to Kushiel’s Dart, has begun! Imyril is hosting the first week’s questions and for the rest of the schedule refer to their post.

This post answers questions for Chapters 1 through 17. Spoilers ahead!

How do you feel about Phèdre returning to the service of Naamah and Joscelin’s reaction to it? Do you sympathize with them?

Like others have said, we wouldn’t have a story if Phèdre didn’t return. Also, she has been pricked by Kushiel’s dart. That’s a rare occurence and seems to include a lifetime of service to the god. Plus, she was never going to let the mystery related to Melisande’s escape go. And she was trained from a young age to be a spy and to serve Naamah. She was ready for a break at the end of the first book but she wasn’t truly ready to retire.

I do sympathize with Joscelin. He loves Phèdre but he seems to be struggling with his true place in the world. He wants to protect and serve but it seems like he preferred to do that in the country and even though it was inevitable that they return he has trouble reconciling everything. I also want to shake him a little.

Why do you think Melisande sent her the cloak?

Part of it is that “genius needs an audience.” And she’s a diabolical chess player.

Any new favorite characters so far? Any thoughts on how Favrielle and Nahum flesh out the world-building?

Favrielle’s situation shows how the indentured servitude works for those who aren’t trained to be servants of Naamah. I love how much of a grump she is and that her talents and hard work make her stand out.

Nahum also presents an interesting situation. They don’t acknowledge the Elua and Companions part of the mythology but they also kind of have to because they live in a land filled with Their descendants. There is also talk of them settling a land in the north for just their people but there is disagreement.

What do you make of the first act mirroring events in Kushiel’s Dart?

I think it makes for a good foundation. We get a summary of previous events, we are given some of the familiar with some of the new elements. The Midwinter Masque Phèdre attends at the palace is slightly different than the one she attended as a child in the Night Court but it also gives us some of the political points that are important going forward.

Other thoughts?

I noted that during the description of the palace room where the Midwinter Masque occured, there was a painting on the wall of Elua and His Companions at a feast. I thought of Leonardo da Vinci’s The Last Supper.

I’m excited to get into this book again!

9 thoughts on “Read As Thou Wilt: Kushiel’s Chosen Week One

  1. Very good point on Kushiel – Joscelin may be done with intrigue and adventure, but you don’t get to retire from being a god’s chosen!

    I’m both intrigued and frustrated by the Yeshuites. I’m enjoying the extension of the world-building, but I have mixed feelings about the way they combine effectively Christian beliefs with Jewish traditions (it feels a little insensitive?). I do find Nahum a lovely character though, and the way he is deeply devout yet clearly not entirely comfortable taking the Word as literal (so doubts Phèdre about the Master of the Straits). On the one hand, this whole subplot feels like padding on a doorstop that’s already got stacks going on – but I’m so glad that regardless of what other priorities have emerged, Phèdre hasn’t forgotten Hyacinthe.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Yeshuite storyline does feel like padding in this book but knowing what happens in the 3rd book it feels like this is meant to be some connecting material between. Jewish and Christian beliefs are connected in complicated ways (plus their connections to Islam). I think it’s good to acknowledge that this world has differing views that are sometimes at odds with each other. I find Nahum to be a sympathetic character, especially in his reaction to the young men running around with swords talking about creating a nation through steel. I don’t think that nation is addressed until the Naamah trilogy (which I haven’t finished yet, I’m on the last book).

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s